Similarly essential are the questions of legitimacy raised by the parties freedom to favor a private form of dispute resolution over national courts. Legal theory of international arbitration ebook, 2010. Lex mercatoria in international arbitration theory and practice volume i mert elcin thesis submitted for assessment with a view to obtaining the degree of doctor of laws of the european university institute florence, november 2012. The first factual scenario refers to the arbitration rules of the international chambers of commerce and the english arbitration act 1996, whereas the second refers to the uncitral arbitration rules and the swiss private international law act. Legal theory of international arbitration by emmanuel gaillard. Progress towards harmonisation national legal and political systems in the 19th century. Delocalization of international commercial arbitration. Why a theory of international arbitration and transnational. Insights for investment treaty dispute resolution 2008 48 virginia journal of international law 767. International arbitration as a transnational system of justice.
The application and development of these principles ensures the functioning of the whole system of international commercial arbitration. Is it feasible and useful to articulate a general theory of transnational legality. Originally from international arbitration law and practice, third edition. The law applicable to veil piercing in international. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Legal theory of international arbitration library nycg 1958. Digital rights management drm the publisher has supplied this book in encrypted form, which means that you need to install free software in order to unlock and read it. The study of international commercial law 8 should trade shirts for shoes until each country has reached its optimal level of consumption.
Doctrine of separability in international commercial. Relationship between the parties and the arbitrator. The firm takes full advantage of the latham network of international offices supported by an advanced, unified, technology platform. Legal theory of international arbitration emmanuel gaillard on. Legal theory of international arbitration by emmanuel. Theory, practice, and implications for australian courts journal of international arbitration, vol. Marchac, interim measures in international commercial arbitration under the icc, aaa, lcia and uncitral rules, 10 am.
It contains a systematic and concise treatment of all aspects of the arbitral process, including international arbitration agreements, international arbitral proceedings and international. Buy legal theory of international arbitration by emmanuel gaillard isbn. As crossborder trade and investment continues to grow, so does the need for fair, neutral and efficient resolution of international commercial disputes. Feminist legal theory is a legacy both of the nineteenth century campaigns for womens emancipation and of the renaissance of feminist activism in the united states and elsewhere since the 1960s. Gaillard, lebal theory if international arbitration martinus nijhoff. Download citation legal theory of international arbitration the present work, based on a course given at the hague academy of international law in the. Gulf of the red sea was settled in favor of egypt by an international arbitration panel, on september 29 1988. The present work, based on a course given at the hague academy of international law in the summer 2007, identifies the philosophical postulates that underlie this field of study and shows their profound coherence and the practical consequences that follow from these postulates in the resolution of international disputes. Emmanuel gaillard international arbitration readily lends itself to a legal theory analysis. International arbitration is arbitration between companies or individuals in different states, usually by including a provision for future disputes in a contract. Download legal theory of international arbitration pdf ebook. The fate of a decision refusing to set aside an award in the legal order of the seat 144. Feminist legal theory manifests through writing and speaking about law and women, in an effort to promote and improve understanding about justice. The overarching theme of my critique is a plea for thinking seriously on why we still.
These include the jurisdiction theory and then the contract, mixed and the autonomous theory. In the first place, there are competing theories of international arbitration, each according a different degree of importance to the seat of arbitration. Theories and theoreticians of international arbitration. Legal theory of international arbitration researchgate. The fundamentally philosophical notions of autonomy and freedom are. Similarly essential are the questions of legitimacy raised by the parties freedom to favor a private form of dispute resolution over national courts, to. International arbitration is arbitration between companies or individuals in different states, usually by including a provision for future disputes in a contract the predominant system of rules is the uncitral arbitration rules, as well as the united nations convention on the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards of 1958 the new york convention. Similarly essential are the questions of legitimacy. Relationship between national and international law. While in theory the parties have a lot of flexibility, is there a certain arbitration culture. Lex mercatoria in international arbitration theory and. International arbitration law readily lends itself to a legal theory analysis.
The present work, based on a course given at the hague academy of international law in the summer 2007, identifies the philosophical postulates that. Jul 01, 2012 buy legal theory of international arbitration by gaillard, emmanuel isbn. Review excerpts from the book on scribd international arbitration readily lends itself to a legal theory analysis. Theory, practice, and law, third edition, features a logical fourpart organization that covers negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and hybrid approaches, which prepares law students to represent clients in all forms of alternative dispute resolution. This facilitates communication and coordination, both internally and. Written by a specialist in international business law, arbitration and legal theory, it examines the discursive framework of arbitral proceedings, through an exploration of the unique status of. Unsurprisingly, it is the application of substantive mandatory rules that creates the most controversy. Feminist legal theory is a set of ideas, an activity engaged in by thinkers in and outside academia, and an. Similarly essential are the questions of legitimacy raised by the parties freedom to favor a private form. A single set of international legal standards for the enforcement of arbitration agreements and awards. Similarly essential are the questions of legitimacy raised by the parties freedom to favor a private form of dispute resolution over national courts, to choose their judges, to tailor the procedure as they.
The impact of ones representation of international arbitration is not merely a question of legal theory and entails significant practical consequences on the representations of international arbitration. Second, enforcement courts have taken contrasting approaches to the decisions at the seat of arbitration. Comparative constitutionalism, trade, foreign policy. International arbitration readily lends itself to a legal theory analysis.
Clayton utz a guide to international arbitration is a straightforward explanation of international arbitration. Nature, extent, and role of parties autonomy in the. Among the theories explored are emmanuel gaillards that international arbitration is relegated to a component of a single national legal order, that international arbitration is anchored in a plurality of national legal orders, and that international arbitration has an autonomous legal order the arbitral legal order. Lex mercatoria in international arbitration theory and practice. Commercial arbitration, he also authored the first published essay on the legal theory of international arbitration. The evolution of international arbitration ashurst. Different visions of the international legal system systems today. Introduction to international commercial arbitration. Piercing in international arbitration juan marcos otazu this paper addresses a significant contemporary issue in international commercial arbitration. Mauro, developing countries visavis international arbitration.
The legal nature of international commercial arbitration. A thesis submitted to the university of manchester for the degree of. For example, country a could trade 20 shirts for 40 pairs of. In choice of law analyses, lex mercatoria addresses specific difficulties relating to the conflict of laws through a principled decision making, such as the applicable conflict rules, and the interpretation of the parties intentions as. It is useful to consider a few of the basic features of arbitration and why it has remained attractive. Introduction increase in international trade and investment is accompanied by growth in crossborder commercial disputes. Legal theory of international arbitration vii c the transnational approach 126 c. While the contract theory claims that arbitration is based exclusively on the agreement between the parties. Alternative dispute resolution approaches and their.
In it, you will learn when to use international arbitration and when not to. Pdf international legal harmonisation in theory and practice. Cairton i summary it is the thesis of this article that the arbitration process is voluntary and con. Analyzing the interplay of the delocalization theory in different legal systems. The fundamentally philosophical notions of autonomy and freedom are at the heart of its field of study. In the theory of law, this book analyses the international legal framework that regulates ecommerce, and its impact on electronic contracting, including model laws and international conventions such as the model law on electronic commerce of 1996 and the electronic communications convention of 2005. Queen mary school of international arbitration and pwc, international. A guide to international arbitration legal services. Given the need for an efficient dispute resolution mechanism, international arbitration has emerged as the preferred option for resolving cross. The predominant system of rules is the uncitral arbitration rules, as well as the united nations convention on the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards of 1958. Gallen, school of management, economics, law, social sciences.
International investment law and sustainable development. International legal harmonisation in theory and practice. Presentation on advocacy techniques in international arbitration. In its most simplistic form, delocalization involves freeing an international arbitration from the constraints of the lex loci arbitri procedural law of the place of arbitration, thereby leaving it to float free of national jurisdiction, irrespective of where the arbitration takes place. Courts frowned on it, though, until attitudes started to change in 1920 with the passage of the first state arbitration law, in new york. Uncitral model law on international commercial arbitration a model law for adoption as part of domestic legislation states have the flexibility to depart from the text model law designed to work in conjunction with the party autonomy and the arbitration rules unless the parties have agreed otherwise. Unsurprisingly, it is the application of substantive mandatory rules that creates. Law and practice second edition provides a comprehensive coverage of the basic principles and legal doctrines, and the practice, of international arbitration. The legal nature of international commercial arbitration and. Pdf legal theory of international arbitration semantic scholar. Uncitral model law on international commercial arbitration 1985, with amendments as adopted in 2006. Msc in construction law and dispute resolution student number. Entrepreneurship, venture capital and law in china europe and world order. Efficiency and flexibility in international commercial arbitration kate davies, wilmer cutler pickering hale and dorr llp 1 2 the search for cost effective and efficient international commercial arbitration.
The doctrine of res judicata before international arbitral tribunals 2 thus, the same or a related dispute might be brought before an arbitral tribunal and a state court or before different arbitral tribunals. Law and contemporary problems voluie 17 autumn, 1952 nunbzr 4 theory of the arbitration process kenneth s. Arbitration in the united states dates to the eighteenth century. Uncitral model law on international commercial arbitration 1985, with amendments as adopted in 2006 an arbitration is international if. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here. The key aspect of arbitration has always been that it is based on agreement between persons. International arbitration has emerged as the principal dispute resolution method for such disputes, but has become hampered in recent years by increasing costs and delays. Stateless law and international arbitration, thomas schultz replies yes and argues, furthermore, that we need such a theory. The representations of international arbitration oxford academic.
Sociology of international arbitration international council for. International business issues are also frequently resolved using arbitration. Introduction for those following debates on the merits of the investment chapters within the transpacific partnership tpp and the transatlantic trade and investment partnership ttip, the answer to the. Though the international community now has a plethora of courts and tribunals at its disposal, for numerous reasons international arbitration remains a central mechanismperhaps even the central mechanism in thirdparty resolution of international commercial disputes.
While most jurisdictions today recognize that the separate legal personality of a corporation can be disregarded to submit the parent company or the. This paper analyzes the delocalization of international commercial arbitration, as a phenomenon which is gaining in popularity in arbitration theory, but in practical terms is still subject to hostility all over the world. This article also describes the main rituals in international arbitration that structure the manner in which social actors are. The present work, based on a course given at the hague academy of international law in the summer 2007, identifies the philosophical postulates that underlie this field of study and shows their profound coherence and the practical consequences that follow from these postulates in. International commercial arbitration law and recent developments in india 1 1.
K 2400 g355 2010 the international effectiveness of the annulment of an arbitral award by hamid g. The consequences of the representations of international arbitration on the fate of the award 5 1. While the contract theory claims that arbitration is based exclusively on the agreement between the parties, the jurisdiction theory argues that arbitration is based on the delegation of the decision making power from the courts to the arbitrators based on the law and the legal system of the state where the arbitration takes place. The paper contends that the role of the seat is far from settled. The fate of an award set aside in the legal order of the seat 5 2.
The law applicable to veil piercing in international arbitration. The attention of arbitration scholars and practitioners is frequently absorbed by the relationship between the parties, which derives from and gives rise to the arbitration agreement. Arbitration is a staple of international dispute resolution. Commission on international trade law model law on international commercial arbitration 1985 art 342aiv and the majority of national arbitration laws provide that awards may set aside and enforcement may be refused if the arbitral procedure in the case was not in accordance with the agreement of the parties. In the course of time, several approaches to the nature and the legal basis of arbitration have evolved. International legal studies courses and reading groups for.
44 370 513 317 1434 1173 1412 382 119 81 390 95 834 465 777 211 1435 77 251 493 1523 958 1434 668 185 692 1484 1177 1471 373 15 681